One of the most common questions asked in nonprofit leadership circles is simple but often debated: Should nonprofit board members be expected fundraise?
My answer is yes. But like many things in the nonprofit world, one size does not fit all.
In theory, the expectation that board members help raise money seems obvious. Nonprofits exist to advance a mission, and that mission requires resources. Board members are fiduciary stewards of the organization, which means they share responsibility for ensuring the financial sustainability of the work.
But in practice, the conversation about fundraising is often far more nuanced.
Too many organizations treat board fundraising expectations as a rigid formula: every board member must raise a certain dollar amount. While the intention behind this is understandable, it can unintentionally limit the value that great board members bring to the table.
In reality, board contribution should be measured in multiple forms of capital, not just financial capital.
Financial Capital
Let’s start with the obvious. Yes, board members should be willing to financially support the organizations they serve. This doesn’t necessarily mean writing the largest check in the room, but it does mean demonstrating personal belief in the mission.
A board member who is unwilling to financially invest in the organization sends a difficult signal to donors, staff, and the community.
But financial giving alone should not define board effectiveness.
Social and Influence Capital
Some of the most impactful board members are not the biggest donors. They are the connectors. They open doors. They introduce the organization to individuals, companies, and institutions that would otherwise never be reached. Their influence expands the nonprofit’s network and credibility.
In these cases, the board member’s greatest contribution is not their personal donation, but their ability to mobilize others.
One introduction can unlock a partnership, a grant opportunity, or a major donor relationship that changes the trajectory of an organization.
Expertise and Strategic Capital
Other board members contribute through professional expertise.
A board member who is an attorney, accountant, marketer, or facilities expert can save an organization tens of thousands of dollars in overhead by providing guidance or pro bono services.
In today’s nonprofit environment, where resources are often stretched thin, this type of contribution is incredibly valuable. If a board member cannot give substantially financially, they should be willing to provide resources that strengthen the organization’s infrastructure. This could include legal guidance, financial expertise, strategic planning support, technology resources, or operational improvements.
Reducing costs is often just as valuable as increasing revenue.
Time and Mission Capital
Finally, there is the investment of time.
Great board members do more than attend quarterly meetings. They show up for the mission. They volunteer. They attend events. They advocate for the organization in their networks and communities.
Their presence reinforces the credibility and visibility of the nonprofit.
In many ways, engaged time is one of the most powerful signals of commitment.
The Real Issue: Clarity
The real problem is not whether board members should fundraise. The real issue is lack of clarity.
Too many nonprofits recruit board members without clearly defining expectations. Then months later frustration begins to surface when board members are unsure of their role in advancing the mission financially.
Healthy organizations address this upfront. They create clear board agreements that outline expectations around giving, influence, service, and engagement. They recognize that each board member may contribute differently, but everyone contributes meaningfully.
A Better Framework
Instead of asking whether board members should fundraise, a better question may be:
“How will each board member contribute to the financial health and mission advancement of this organization?”
For some, that answer will be writing a significant check.
For others, it will be opening doors to donors and partners.
For others, it will be providing expertise that saves the organization money.
And for many, it will be a combination of all three.
What matters most is that every board member actively strengthens the mission they have committed to serve. Because ultimately, board membership is not just about governance. It is about stewardship.
|
|
Thank you again for subscribing. I look forward to embarking on this exciting journey with you!
To a more productive you
|
11016 Quivira Rd Unit #747, Overland Park, KS 66210
Unsubscribe · Preferences